Should every time the Moon appears in the sky be counted as an appearances or should it be just for notable appearances? If we went with the latter then that would leave out stuff like the full Moon supposedly bringing the Black Knight to life. In that respect, perhaps that would be a counted as something notable, but happens just in the history. Leave the close-up appearances of the Moon for the Appearances section?
Looks good. I have not watched the "Moon Monster Madness" and so I couldn't offer an opinion on the setting, but it seems to me you did right. If action takes place on the surface of the Moon, then it's a setting. Otherwise not.
Not to spoil it, but it is a setting. The official plot says they go to the Moon, anyway. So setting = appearance? So I guess whatever happens in What a Night for a Knight, etc. then it should just stick to the history section.
I don't know how much from here has been copied, as from what I saw on the activity list was pretty random, but you can clearly see that it's virtually identical. The only difference is the colour of the infobox. Our home page was probably too complex to carry over.
Just in case you haven't seen the overhaul I've been given episodes (starting right from the first episode), maybe you can tell me what you think. I was wondering if the Full credits section should be turned into a table or be done in bullet points instead. The gallery, in case you're wondering, is for behind-the-scenes stuff, I just haven't added anything yet.
I like the main image/ title card image boxes. The different kinds of things (objects, locations, vehicles, etc.) is also nice. I think the Full Credits could be done with simple bullet items. Making it a centered table that has to be expanded is a bit awkward.
A recent editor has added several dozen pages with categories we will never use, I would try to remove this with the AWB I downloaded for myself, but it constantly fails to load. So if there's an opportunity for you to remove them, I would appreciate it.
I wrote a civil message to Loonytoonarian on his Looney Tunes wall, explaining our reasons for the ban. He was very rude, and asked me to pass on the message that you are in "big trouble" when his ban is lifted, and that we are "enemies." I think the threat merits an extended ban.
I've done screen captures from Amazon and the images are clean of play/pause bars. Also, on Windows you can just do print screen as a video is running and it will capture what is on the screen at that instant (it can be hard to get the timing correct, though).
If something on home video is called something different in another country and has different content does it warrant its own page? For example, Scooby-Doo! 13 Spooky Tales: Field of Screams is just Scooby-Doo! Field of Screams in the UK and only has the first disc.
All of Ink-Doo's images need to be deleted as they are misnamed (and not even in english) and they were obviously just going to float around just looking pretty with no use being made out of them. I also don't know where they're from (although I can take I guess, but that's not the point) and I doubt I'd get a straight forward reply of where they were from as with most users who can't be bothered to answer this simple request.
Either you're an editor there or some of your edits are being transferred over there. Apparently I made an enemy because I've been blocked out of spite before having done one single edit. Admittingly though, they do have a couple of rule pages we should have already. The ironic thing is we could be seen as copying. It's actually not the first rival wiki I've seen. (I jumped the gun on that crossed out part.)
Because of attribution some of your edits get acknowledged. Although the funny thing is it says the same date you started here.
I was thinking of having a subsection under notes/trivia (well, really underneath its misc. subsection) that lists real-world references. I'm not sure about the references within almost every episode of SDMI because they're not acknowledged by any of the characters themselves (except for when Fred mentioned in a couple of episodes about his "trapping sense tingling"), although it probably would make sense just to add them anyway, regardless. What do you think?
I think it's appropriate to put real-world references there, as you suggest. It's really the only place for refs the in-universe characters cannot possibly acknowledge, like a name of a person or product that parodies a real-world name.
Do we need a news section because the forum activity list pretty much covers that? I was thinking instead though, to just have a new releases section for DVD, comics, etc. If I can just keep it up to date.